Monday, May 11, 2015

Elsinore way ; The Dilemma



Hamlet's Dilemma is one of those scenes that's causes you to place yourself in a pair of shoe that you would never think of wearing. It causes you to think of when is the perfect time to kill someone. Throughout Hamlet's dilemma, he believed that killing Claudius at the right time would send him where he should be; hell. In this scene Claudius selfishness is highlighted and shows that even though he wants forgiveness he still wants his power. Most times people are willing to trade their self respect to either maintain or receive power. Hamlet’s Dilemma provides audience with the opportunity to see that even family will turn on you to gain what they believe is owed to them.


    A man should never take away another man’s life especially if one did not grant it. The legal system in America has eliminated the death penalty and most cultures elsewhere stone or resort to other form of torture as their death penalty. In Exodus 20:13 KJV, as a part of the 10 Commandments, it states thou shall not kill. No man is exempt from this commandment nor is he above the power of the Lord. In my opinion, Claudius act of prayer was done to let him feel good about repenting but it was not done out of sincerity.


It is obvious that Claudius is guilty based on the ghost’s recalling of events, his reaction to Hamlets play and his confession through prayer. If he had not done such crime he would not be king nor would he had the opportunity of marrying Gertrude. If Hamlet goes ahead and kill Claudius there are two possible outcomes. He could get locked up or majority of the citizens would defend him and plea insanity. Murder is a cruel act which goes against moral rights and the Lord’s Commandments and often presents the question of when is it ethical to kill someone and can murder be justifiable. 

No comments:

Post a Comment